Poop Bag Showdown
Poop Bag Showdown: Which Earth Rated Bag Is Best for Your Dog’s Waste?
If you’re a dog parent, picking up poop is a daily duty — but not all dog poop bags are created equal. Some tear. Some leak. Some smell terrible (or try too hard to smell good). And others are a delight to use (yes, really).
Earth Rated is one of the most trusted brands on Amazon, offering several eco-conscious and ultra-durable poop bag options. But between their new Green Plant-Based Unscented Bags and their classic Unscented Refill Rolls, which should you choose?
We’ve compared the two side-by-side to help you pick the right fit for your walks, values, and pup.
Earth Rated Dog Poop Bags – Green Plant-Based Unscented
- Sustainable supply for daily walks – Stay ready for every outing with 1080 PET N PET dog waste bags (60 rolls, each with…
- Plant-powered for a gentler impact – Made with 41% USDA Certified biobased materials, these bags are crafted using plant…
- Made for every pet and every path – With a generous 9 x 13 inch size, these bags fit most dispensers and handle cleanup …
Highlights:
- Made with 38% plant-based materials (bioplastic).
- Standard size (9” x 13”) fits most leash dispensers.
- Unscented, clean finish, no overwhelming fragrance.
- Strong enough for medium to large dogs.
- Easy-tear perforation.
Pros:
- Eco-friendlier choice — partially plant-based, made with sustainability in mind.
- Good thickness for odor control and durability.
- Compatible with Earth Rated and most other dispensers.
Cons:
- Slightly stiffer material can make opening tricky, especially in cold or wet weather.
- Not certified for home composting (not backyard compost-safe).
- Some users report tightness in standard dispensers.
Best For:
Dog owners who want an eco-upgrade to classic plastic bags without losing strength or convenience — great for casual walks and responsible cleanup.
Earth Rated Dog Poop Bags – Unscented Refill Rolls (Classic)
- DOG POOP BAGS: Our durable poop bags are a dog-walking essential. They are extremely portable and pair perfectly with th…
- 100% LEAK-PROOF CONSTRUCTION: These dog poop bags are extra long, extra strong, and 100% leak-proof, ensuring that your …
- EASY-TO-USE: To use, pull one of our poop bags away from the roll and tear on the built-in line. With the “3 Bags Left” …
Highlights:
- Thicker plastic (15 microns) with excellent leak protection.
- Unscented and made with 65% recycled materials.
- Large size (13” x 9”) — roomy enough for big messes.
- Includes “3 bags left” indicator on each roll.
- B Corp certified — ethical and environmental focus.
Pros:
- Top-rated poop bag on Amazon — over 100,000+ reviews.
- Extra thick and durable, even with large or messy waste.
- Smooth unrolling and reliable tearing.
Cons:
- Made from recycled plastic, not biodegradable.
- Slightly more expensive per bag than generic alternatives.
Best For:
Pet parents who want maximum durability, leak-proof reliability, and don’t mind a few extra cents per walk. Ideal for dogs of all sizes.
Bestseller Picks
Final Verdict: Which Should You Choose?
Both Earth Rated options are solid picks — it depends on what matters most to you.
- Choose the Green Plant-Based bags if:
- You’re looking to reduce your environmental footprint.
- You prefer a smoother, cleaner unscented experience.
- You want a smaller, more compact box size.
- Choose the Unscented Refill Rolls if:
- You want maximum strength, thickness, and value.
- You have a larger dog or messier cleanups.
- You rely on reliability and performance every single time.
Both get the job done — it just comes down to your values and routine.
❓ Foire Aux Questions (FAQ)
Are Earth Rated poop bags biodegradable?
Not all. The green plant-based version uses 38% bioplastics but is not home compostable. The classic refill rolls are made from recycled plastic, but they are not biodegradable.
Can these bags be used in a standard dispenser?
Yes. Both the green and refill versions are designed to fit most leash-style poop bag dispensers.
Do they leak or tear easily?
No. Both versions are highly durable, with the Refill Rolls being especially leak-proof and thicker than average.